Here’s What the New Benefit Cosmetics Highlighters Look Like on 2 Editors

"Cookie" is my favourite shade of the two, it's perfect for my light skin tone and gives just the right amount of shimmer without being glittery. It's also a colour I'll definitely wear on my eyelids and collarbones if I'm feeling super fancy. I feel confident that I'd even be able to add foundation on top of this highlighter and it would still shine through. — Tori Crowther, assistant editor

Whenever deciding on makeup, I immediately go for coral hues because of my yellow undertone. Surprisingly, although "Cookie" looks golden in the pot, it's actually a silvery-toned highlighter. I really like that it gives my skin a dewy look. — Kara Kia, editorial assistant

"Tickle" is definitely more golden than "Cookie", which I think works better for darker skin tones. However, I still loved how it looked on my complexion. The colour isn't as pink as it looks in the box, but definitely has a hint of rosiness to it. It's a great option if you aren't a fan of blush but want a bit of pink to your makeup. I'll wear "Tickle" for evenings out or when I'm a bit more tanned, and when I want my highlighter to be a little more noticeable. — TC

Pink makeup scares me! Anyone with tanned skin can relate. But as much as "Tickle" looks pink, it actually has a golden shimmer that is perfect for deeper skin tones. I love a bronzed look in the Summer, so I would definitely add a bit of "Tickle" on top of my bronzer for a bit of extra glow on my cheekbones. — KK