Update Consent

Best Sephora Halloween Makeup to Buy in 2020

The Sephora Products to Make Halloween Makeup Magic, No Matter Your Costume

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

While it's hard to picture the packed parties of Halloweens past, that doesn't mean dressing up has to be on hold this year. After all, if holiday hangouts end up online, our faces are front and centre, especially when it comes to costumes. In fact, it could even be argued that makeup will become even more important in 2020 since we may be trick-or-treating our own cabinets and seeing our friends virtually from the neck up.

Since we're never not planning when it comes to October 31, we poked around at Sephora to see which beauty products can get your creative juices flowing and will also be just as sweet come November 1, too.

Ahead, find our top picks for Halloween makeup stocked at Sephora — because it's definitely not too soon to get started.

Image Source: Sephora

Make Up For Ever Flash Colour Palette Multi-use Cream Colour Palette

You're only limited by your imagination with this top-rated Make Up For Ever Flash Colour Palette Multi-use Cream Colour Palette ($99). Each of the 12 creamy colours can be used solo on your lids or lips, blended into foundation for other special effects on your face, or applied anywhere on your body with a tool like this Artis Elite Mirror Oval 10 Brush ($80).

Image Source: sephora.com
Make Up For Ever Flash Colour Palette Multi-use Cream Colour Palette
$99
from sephora.com
Buy Now
Artis Elite Mirror Oval 10 Brush
$80
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Museum of Ice Cream x Sephora Collection Rainbow Sherbet Lash

There's nothing ordinary about these Museum of Ice Cream x Sephora Collection Rainbow Sherbet Lashes ($7, originally $18). The colourful feathers offer a touch of unexpected whimsy that's an unmissable costume addition no matter what you've got planned this year.

Image Source: sephora.com
Museum of Ice Cream x Sephora Collection Rainbow Sherbet Lashes
$7
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Lilly Lashes Living My Best Life Collection

The four options in this limited-edition Lilly Lashes Living My Best Life Collection ($30) are big on drama. After all, these false lashes, and others in the brand's popular Lilly Lashes 3D Mink ($30) series, can add glam to any Halloween look — just grab some Duo Eyelash Adhesive ($9) so you're set come October.

Image Source: sephora.com
Lilly Lashes Living My Best Life Collection
$30
from sephora.com
Buy Now
Lilly Lashes 3D Mink
$30
from sephora.com
Buy Now
Duo Eyelash Adhesive
$9
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Anastasia Beverly Hills Loose Glitter

There are six shades of Anastasia Beverly Hills Loose Glitter ($15) so you can sparkle wherever, whenever (but especially on October 31). It works really well when applied with this Too Faced Glitter Glue Eye Shadow Primer ($22) on your lids, but there's no reason why this can't be spread elsewhere on your body with other glitter glue, too.

Image Source: sephora.com
Anastasia Beverly Hills Loose Glitter
$15
from sephora.com
Buy Now
Too Faced Glitter Glue Eye Shadow Primer
$22
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Watch This!

Pop Quiz

Watch the Cast of Fear Street Play a Creepy Game of Horror Movie "Would You Rather"

Urban Decay Heavy Metal Face and Body Glitter Gel - Sparkle Out Loud Collection

Cut out the middle step when applying loose glitter and opt for this highly concentrated, quick-drying Urban Decay Heavy Metal Face and Body Glitter Gel - Sparkle Out Loud Collection ($22) instead. It's already suspended in water-based gel so it will last for the entire party, workday, or night out trick-or-treating (for up to nine hours).

Image Source: sephora.com
Urban Decay Heavy Metal Face and Body Glitter Gel - Sparkle Out Loud Collection
$22
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Urban Decay Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner

For a more targeted sparkle, this Urban Decay Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner ($21) comes in 16 colours each packed into a long-wearing, clear base with conditioning fruit and vegetable extracts inside, too. Add a solo line of glitter or top your favourite shadow using its thin brush, or just tap anywhere else you like with your fingers.

Or, if your masquerade plans require a detailed drawing on your skin, there's also this waterproof Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil - Sparkle Out Loud Collection ($22) for a crayon-like effect instead.

Image Source: sephora.com
Urban Decay Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner
$21
from sephora.com
Buy Now
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil - Sparkle Out Loud Collection
$22
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Sephora Collection Colourful Eyeshadow

If you love eyeshadow experimentation on a regular day, Halloween is likely no different. When costumes call for a shade not in your personal stash (yet), there's a Sephora Collection Colourful Eyeshadow ($9) to solve that problem — there are 80+ colours to choose.

Image Source: sephora.com
Sephora Collection Colourful Eyeshadow
$9
from sephora.com
Buy Now

KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Vegan Eyeliner, Shadow and Brow Pigment

These versatile KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Vegan Eyeliner, Shadow and Brow Pigments ($20) can add a streak to your lids or even your eyebrows. If your ensemble calls for a wig or temporary hair colour, there's a rainbow of hues to match, but there are traditional hair shades, too. (Just use a finger or the KVD Vegan Beauty #70 Pomade Brow Brush ($18) meant for this exact product.)

Image Source: sephora.com
KVD Vegan Beauty Super Pomade Vegan Eyeliner, Shadow and Brow Pigments
$20
from sephora.com
Buy Now
KVD Vegan Beauty #70 Pomade Brow Brush
$18
from sephora.com
Buy Now

KVD Vegan Beauty Studded Kiss Crème Lipstick

There's no worry about this KVD Vegan Beauty Studded Kiss Crème Lipstick ($5-$20, originally $20) coming off while you sip some witches' brew — all 20+ colours are long-lasting and lip-nourishing at the same time.

Image Source: sephora.com
KVD Vegan Beauty Studded Kiss Crème Lipstick
$5
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Gothique Metallic Lipstick

All nine shimmery shades of this Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Gothique Metallic Lipstick ($46) feature a deep-black undertone, whether you opt to make a statement with bold Gucci red, or pick a more unique colour like grey blue, silvery pink, or evergreen instead.

Image Source: sephora.com
Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Gothique Metallic Lipstick
$46
from sephora.com
Buy Now

KVD Vegan Beauty Everlasting Liquid Lipstick

If we had to pick just one KVD Vegan Beauty Everlasting Liquid Lipstick ($5-$21, originally $11-$21) for All Hallows' Eve, it'd surely be this pitch black colour . . . but don't just take our word for it, check out the other shades, too.

Image Source: sephora.com
KVD Vegan Beauty Everlasting Liquid Lipstick
$5
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Nails Inc. Unicorn Nail Polish Duo

Maybe a new nail polish is as much of a costume as you're willing to commit to thus far? No matter what Halloween looks like in 2020, this iridescent Nails Inc. Unicorn Nail Polish Duo ($15) can mystify long after the pumpkins are carved, and the Nails Inc. Colour Changing Nail Polish Duo- Are You Hot Or Not ($15) will turn your nails into chameleons as the temperature changes throughout the day (and year).

Image Source: sephora.com
Nails Inc. Unicorn Nail Polish Duo
$15
from sephora.com
Buy Now
Nails Inc. Colour Changing Nail Polish Duo- Are You Hot Or Not
$15
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Ciaté London The Cheat Sheets Nail Stickers

These Ciaté London The Cheat Sheets Nail Stickers ($18) are not only a quick way to add nail art, they make a mighty fine finishing touch this Halloween (or a low-key costume on their own). It's hard to pick just one fave in this set, but the evil eyes and pastel leopard spots definitely stick out.

Love all things beauty? Can't get enough products? Come join our Facebook Group, Real Reviews With POPSUGAR Beauty There are lots of fun conversations happening there, as well as all the product recommendations you could ask for — not just from us, but also community members, too.

Image Source: sephora.com
Ciaté London The Cheat Sheets Nail Stickers
$18
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Want More?

POPSUGAR Would Like To Send You Push Notifications.