Skip Nav

Could a Non-American Ever Win American Idol?

American Idol's Carly Smithson looked happy to be returning to the mother country as she arrived in Dublin with her husband yesterday. I thought Carly and Australian Michael Johns were great contestants and possible Idol winners, but Carly got voted out mid-way through and Michael didn't even make the top seven. I'm not sure a non-American could ever be voted the winner, but I want to know what you think. So tell me: could a non-American ever win American Idol?


Latest Celebrity