Just when I thought I couldn't love Grocery Store Joe any more, he ended up with another fan favourite, Kendall, and now I'm grinning like an idiot over the lovable Bachelor in Paradise [1] couple. Fans of The Bachelorette [2] lost their minds over Joe Amabile [3], following his short but memorable appearance on Becca's season, and viewers had high hopes for him going into Paradise. Luckily, he really did find his happily ever after (YAY!) — plus a Dancing With the Stars gig [4] to boot.

Joe and Kendall had some ups and downs in Paradise [5], but even though they didn't leave Mexico together, the pair managed to reunite post-filming and give their relationship another chance. During the season finale, they said they were still in love, and soon after the show aired, each of them posted a sweet message on Instagram. "Love is an odd yet wonderful mess that makes those affected do quite strange things but through it all I would do it again and again and again if it meant waking up next to this odd-ball of a human every morning," Kendall wrote. "I love you mucho Joe!" Keep reading to see the couple's adorable posts, plus some of their cutest moments they shared on Bachelor in Paradise.