The Fab Five of Netflix's Queer Eye [1] — Jonathan Van Ness, Karamo Brown, Tan France, Antoni Porowski, and Bobby Berk — have formed a strong bond [2] through their work on the show [3], but how well do they really know each other? Well, their friendship was put to the test on Tuesday in a round of "Know Your Fab Five" on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon [4]. During the game, Antoni, Tan, and Jonathan took turns wearing a pair of noise-canceling headphones, while the others answered a question about whoever couldn't hear.

Naturally, we got quite a bit of insight into some of their funniest moments and Hollywood gaffes that we don't get to see on screen when they're changing people's lives [5]. One of the best anecdotes Tan revealed is when he totally mistook a certain Game of Thrones [6] actor — one of the main characters — for someone else, calling him a completely different name while they spoke. Awkward! Above, watch him detail the story and find out more about the Fab Five's hilarious experiences (including the time Jonathan desperately needed a tissue)!