Don't you just love catching up with your former beaus about your current love life? No? Tell that to exes Sarah Silverman [1] and Jimmy Kimmel [2], who just had a hilariously awkward conversation about the state of their romantic relationships during Jimmy Kimmel Live! [3] on Wednesday night. Sarah stopped by the show to promote her new series I Love You, America, when Jimmy inquired about her dating life since her split from Michael Sheen last year [4] — and her response was gold.

"What's going on with me dating-wise? I'm waiting for this tryst with you to be over," she joked, referring to Jimmy's marriage to his show's co-head writer, Molly McNearney. "I mean, OK, Molly is cute. She's bright, she's funny, she's blonde — whatever. But come on!" She later joked about no longer seeing him as a "sexual being" anymore. See more of their exchange in the video above.