Gilmore Girls: 5 Plausible Theories About THAT Cliffhanger

Warning: major spoilers below!

We're in an emotional tailspin after watching Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, and we need answers. Since it was only intended to be a one-time thing, Netflix hasn't ordered a second season and we're afraid we'll never know — seriously, if you haven't heard the final four words, stop reading immediately — who the father of Rory's baby is. Sure, we're still rooting for her to end up with Jess (did you catch that meaningful glance?), but unless they secretly slept together, he's not the father. Before this turns into an episode of Maury, let's lay out the most plausible options.