Andrew Garfield [1] isn't just the lead in Hulu's haunting series "Under the Banner of Heaven [2]." He's also a skilled knitter, a passionate singer, and (through impressive commitment to these jokes) a fearless crimefighter and a prolific lasso-er.

We sat down with this multitalented star and his costars Daisy Edgar Jones [3], Gil Birmingham, Chloe Pirrie, and Tyner Rushing to see how they kept things light while creating a show with such heavy subject matter. Their answers included the types of activities we all seek out: oysters at a restaurant, binging "Squid Game" [4], and, according to Garfield, some much-needed cuddling.

Have you ever seen a laugh this pure?

For all the fun, watch the video above — and check out the decidedly more serious "Under the Banner of Heaven" streaming now on Hulu.