It's probably not surprising at all that the PEN15 actors look very different in real life than they do on screen! Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle, who also co-created the Hulu comedy, star as fictionalized versions of their middle school selves, and that means styling themselves like middle schoolers: bad fashion and regrettable haircuts and all.

In real life, though, they're both super stylish women in Hollywood, with their own unique sense of fashion and a much more confident presence. Ahead of the second season, which is set to debut on Sept. 18, keep reading to compare some of their real-life appearances to how they look on screen — you'll barely even recognise them!