Emilia and Seth reportedly began dating in 2012 but split a year later due to long distance. In Glamour's May 2016 issue, Emilia opened up about the problem with dating a celebrity, saying, "Well, a con is you have strangers giving you love-life advice like, 'I'm a big fan of the show, and I'm not sure what you're doing with that guy,' which I didn't react well to. That happened in New York when Seth and I were together. This guy started to give me advice: 'Can I get a selfie? And by the way . . .' Unh-unh, bro."