Contestants who get sent home on the first episode of The Bachelor [1] or The Bachelorette [2] typically don't make a lasting impression. But Chris Harrison said it himself [3] — Bachelor Nation quickly fell in love with Joe Amabile, nicknamed Grocery Store Joe. That's why we're so excited that the Chicago-based guy is headed to Bachelor in Paradise [4]! We wonder if he'll bring his own produce for those frozen cocktails . . . But before we watch his journey for love, you'll want to check out his Instagram for pictures of his adorable smile [5].