Twenty-seven years later and, yep, you guessed it: everyone's least-favourite demented clown is back in the poor town of Derry once more. With the all-new It Chapter 2 [1], Pennywise has returned [2] in the year 2016 with the older and wiser Losers Club [3] reuniting to try to defeat the dancing clown once and for all.

In celebration of the sequel, we sat down with the cast to play a round of horror movie "would you rather," [4] where they were tasked with making some incredibly hard decisions — including if they'd rather open a bag of Doritos in A Quiet Place [5] or unload the dishwasher in the Jurassic Park [6] kitchen . . .

. . . and deciding which group they'd rather have knock on their door: their "tethered" doppelgängers from Us [7] or a pack of killers from The Purge [8].

Check out the full video above, and watch Pennywise in action once again when It Chapter 2 hits theatres Friday, Sept. 6!