That was then. This is now. #JesusChristSuperstar [1] pic.twitter.com/hxlkt3eTkC [2]

— Jesus Christ Superstar (@JCSTheMusical) April 2, 2018 [3]

John Legend had the crowd on their feet praising him for his portrayal of Jesus Christ [4] during NBC's Jesus Christ Superstar Live [5] on Sunday night. But it wasn't until his magical performance of "Gethsemane" that every single person watching immediately had chills running down their spines in awe of his vocals. It was one of the most jaw-dropping moments of the entire live musical, and even Chrissy Teigen admitted her husband was nervous for this song [6]. Watch the incredible performance above, and then, check out all the thoughts fans had while watching Jesus Christ Superstar Live [7].

He won't say it but I know he was nervous for that song. So good!!

— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) April 2, 2018 [8]

Gethsemane - the song where @johnlegend [9] made the role his own. #JesusChristSuperStarLive [10] pic.twitter.com/7nxyoIzoVb [11]

— Paul Brandeis Raushenbush (@raushenbush) April 2, 2018 [12]

Gethsemane!!!!@johnlegend NOT playing safe. Laying all out there! Just jumped to my feet for second time!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 #JesusChristSuperstarLive [13]

— Aaron Tveit (@AaronTveit) April 2, 2018 [14]

What. Just. Happened. John Legend just gave the best performance Gethsemane ever, and it's not close.#JesusChristSuperstarLive [15] #JesusChristSuperstar [16]

— Baylor Travis Hurst (@BaylorTravis) April 2, 2018 [17]