Despite the fact that the entire festival was filmed, the footage sat in a basement for 50 years and had never seen the light of day — that is, until now. The reason for that? Black erasure. Woodstock also was held that same summer, 100 miles away from the Harlem Cultural Festival, and completely eclipsed it. When director Hal Tulchin tried to sell footage from the Harlem Cultural Festival to movie or TV outlets, nobody was interested.
Questlove stumbled across the festival footage years ago at the Soul Train Café in Japan. "I unknowingly saw two minutes of the Sly and the Family Stone performance on monitors inside the restaurant, but it was sort of a far-away shot and I couldn't see the faces in the crowd. So I thought it was a film clip of Sly and the group performing somewhere in Europe," Questlove told Billboard. "Backstage at The Tonight Show 20 years later, I'm told about this mythical festival featuring Sly, Nina Simone, Stevie Wonder, and more. I didn't think it was real — because there's no way you're going to tell me that Nina, Stevie, and Sly appeared together at a festival and no one knew or cared about it. Then I thought there must be some bad footage, as with old eight millimeter films. However, when I was shown the footage and heard the sound, it was all perfect."
He continued, "The sad truth is that Black erasure is real. It's very easy to just dismiss our stories. When Prince released his autobiography, he talked about his dad taking him to Woodstock and how much that meant to him as an 11-year-old; what a paradigm shift it was. The whole time I'm watching this footage, I'm thinking, 'OK, I made it here. But what about the other six billion then-future musicians that could have been changed by this movie?' We lost a moment and an opportunity. I made every excuse in the world for that because, again, I have faith in mankind that no one would be that cruel to deny history like that."
Summer of Soul is now in theatres and available to stream on Hulu.