Update Consent

Review of Bestselling Sweaters From Old Navy | 2020

4 Editors Put Old Navy's Famous Cosy Sweaters to the Test — Read Their 100% Real Reviews

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

OK, my hoodies need a break. I have taken my athleisure game perhaps a little too far in 2020, and I'm ready to step things up for fall with something more elevated. Sweaters are a solid start. The cosy staple is just as comfortable to wear, but more versatile for entering the outside world. There are millions of styles out there, but which one is best for you? I decided to start at Old Navy — the brand is known for its affordable knits.

To give you the ultimate online shopping experience, I enlisted my fellow shopping editors to each test out a different bestselling sweater from the site and serve up their honest reviews. Ahead, see how each editor styled their knit, then consider an option for yourself. Channelling those cosy vibes is about to get 10 times easier.

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography

The Classic Mock-Neck Sweater

The Style: Old Navy Cosy Shaker-Stitch Mock-Neck Sweater ($40)

The Review: "I still can't believe the affordable price tag on this sweater, because the shaker-stitch weave and luxurious fabric make it both look and feel like a $100 find. It's incredibly soft and the navy blue option goes great with jeans. I love it so much I just bought it in grey as well. If you don't believe me, read all the five-star reviews on the site." — Macy Cate Williams, senior editor, Shop

Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com
Old Navy Cosy Shaker-Stitch Mock-Neck Sweater
$40
from oldnavy.gap.com
Buy Now

The Versatile Wear-It-Anywhere Sweater

The Style: Old Navy Cosy Textured Crew-Neck Sweater ($30, originally $37)

The Review: "This sweater is perfect for kicking back at home, or looking put together on Zoom calls. The relaxed silhouette makes it a no-brainer for my lounge game, and the textured fabric brings a layer of warmth. I'll be wearing it on repeat." — Shelcy Joseph, assistant editor, Shop

Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com
Old Navy Cosy Textured Crew-Neck Sweater
$30
from oldnavy.gap.com
Buy Now

The Cosy Half-Zip Knit

The Style: Old Navy Mock-Neck 1/4-Zip Sweater ($40, originally $45)

The Review: "I own more classic crewneck sweaters than I can even count, but this season I wanted to try something a little more versatile. The design is easy to wear with jeans when I leave the house, or pair with my sweats when I'm lounging at home. No matter how I style it, I just can't get over how soft and cosy it is." — Krista Jones, associate editor, Shop

Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com
Old Navy Mock-Neck 1/4-Zip Sweater
$40
from oldnavy.gap.com
Buy Now

The Quintessential Fall Sweater

The Style: Old Navy Cosy Pointelle-Knit Crew-Neck Sweater ($38, origially $40)

The Review: "This sweater is incredibly comfortable! I love that I can wear it as work from home loungewear as well as out to dinner or a pumpkin patch. It's convenient to be able to dress it up or down. It's pretty thick and warm so it's perfect for the upcoming chilly weather — coming from someone who lives in the northeast. It comes in gorgeous earth-toned autumn colours. I chose a size XS and it's a loose, oversized fit. This definitely embodies cosy fall vibes." — Anvita Reddy, editorial coordinator, Shop

Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com
Old Navy Cosy Pointelle-Knit Crew-Neck Sweater
$38
from oldnavy.gap.com
Buy Now

Want More?

POPSUGAR Would Like To Send You Push Notifications.