For Mandy Moore's next trick, she will pull high-fashion out of a hat! The This Is Us-nominated actress made a sophisticated and stylish appearance on Critics' Choice red carpet on Sunday night, wearing a strapless jumpsuit and a matching cape. The magician at my fifth birthday party could never.

The sleek Elie Saab number features delicate metallic detailing across her midsection, perfectly tying in the sparkling Anita Ko jewlery on her neck, ears, and fingers. Mandy's stylist Cristina Ehrlich finished the look off with a pair of classic black Louboutin, a failsafe at any award show. Keep reading to see more of Mandy's outfit before she *poof* disappears for the night.