4. Old Navy Extra High-Waisted Rockstar 360° Stretch Super Skinny Button-Fly Jeans Sure, it's a small detail, but the exposed buttons on these Old Navy Extra High-Waisted Rockstar 360° Stretch Super Skinny Button-Fly Jeans ($40) set them apart from the rest of the stretchy, slimming options in this fabric. Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com Old Navy Extra High-Waisted Rockstar 360° Stretch Super Skinny Button-Fly Jeans $40 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now NEXT GALLERY Target Released Halloween BaubleBar Earrings So Cute, We Want All 8 Pairs (Under $15!) by Anvita Reddy