When it comes to shopping for workout [1] tights, there are a number of factors to keep in mind. The first, of course, is thinking about what activity you'll be dressing for — cycling, for example, can be really uncomfortable in a pair of shorts — and then considering any other needs you'll have. I for one need pockets on my tights when I go to the gym because I hate trying to balance all of my things on a weight bench when I'd rather just be hands-free. I'd heard a ton of buzz about Old Navy activewear [2], so I decided it was time to try out its most popular styles. See how they stacked up!
Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings
I tested the High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings For Women [4] ($50) to see how they'd perform in a Pilates reformer class. I have certain tights I wear for specific workouts, and I wanted something that was flattering but would move with me in even the most awkward of positions.
Best For Pilates: High-Waisted Elevate Built-In Sculpt 7/8-Length Compression Leggings
It was clear to me the minute I put these on that this legging was about movement much more than sweat-wicking. Boy could I move my legs! These are also incredibly snug. I was fearful that that might restrict my movement in class, but it wasn't the case. I had all of the mobility I needed. And the best part about these leggings is that I never had to tug them up in class. They definitely stay in place. There are a number of things that can go wrong with your wardrobe in a Pilates reformer class, but my pet peeve would have to be accidentally wearing tights with a zipper on the back. I'm happy to report that these not only are completely zipper-free, but they felt seam-free against my skin, even while lying on my side.
Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings
Next I tested the High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings For Women [5] ($40) to see how the pair delivered when it came to pockets.
Best For Pockets: Old Navy High-Waisted Elevate Powersoft 7/8-Length Side-Pocket Leggings
Side pockets are everything to me, but just because a pant has them doesn't mean they can hold up to the pressure. I'm someone who stuffs a lot into their pockets, and I almost never use waistband zippers anymore because they can barely hold anything. I wore these tights to see how much I could shove into the pockets, and whether or not anything would fall out during a weight-training session.
I'm happy to report that while doing legs, I managed to fit my wallet, keys, and cell phone into the pockets, enabling me to be completely hands-free during my workout. And throughout squats, lunges, and other lifts, nothing budged or pushed against my skin.
Old Navy High-Waisted Run Leggings
Lastly I tested the High-Waisted Run Leggings [6]($33) for running because I'm very specific about my running tights. I need something high-rise so I never have to think about tugging my pants up, and I need to be able to move my legs freely should I get a burst of energy and want to sneak in a few sprints.
Best For Running: Old Navy High-Waisted Run Leggings
The second I put these on I knew they were meant for running. They were much firmer than the other tights I tested, but I still had full range. The waistband was considerably higher than my other running tights, and I think that's what helped them stay in place. I loved the slight sheen to them, and there are breathable mesh panels on the backside of the knee which made moving easier.