Cookie monsters, sweet tooths, and dessert fans [1], it's your time to shine. Goldbelly [2] has an incredible selection of unique and beloved cookies [3] from all over the nation, and we rounded up the best ones. We're talking cookie fries, cookie doughnuts, a five-pound sea-salt caramel chocolate chip cookie, giant black-and-white frosted cookies, and more. Even a self-proclaimed cookie connoisseur will have a hard time choosing between these deliciously scrumptious options. If you're a Barefoot Contessa fan, you can even indulge in Ina Garten's Favourite Cookies. With the right amount of crispiness and gooeyness [4], you'll fall in love with these sweet treats. Shop our top picks ahead!
Beloved Chocolate Chip Cookies: Jacques' World Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies
The contents of this 12-pack of Jacques' World Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies [6] ($70 for 12) are by far the most heavenly chocolate chip cookies. They are perfectly soft and gooey and have such a melt-in-your-mouth, decadent flavour. You can't go wrong with something classic, comforting, and delish.
A Gooey Option: Gooey on the Inside Choose Your Own Half Dozen Jumbo Cookies
If you favour gooey cookies over crispy ones, the Gooey on the Inside Choose Your Own Half Dozen Jumbo Cookies [7] ($55 for six) are a must. You can choose between chocolate chip chunk, birthday cake, chocolate chip peanut butter, churro and Nutella, Cuppa Joe Exotic, and Dunkaroo. We recommend getting one of each.
For Doughnut-Lovers: Stan's Donuts Donut Cookies
If you love doughnuts as much as you love cookies, the Stan's Donuts Donut Cookies [8] ($49 for 12) are the perfect blend of both. They come with three Chi-Town Chunk cookies,
two M&M's cookie, two Raisin' The Bar on Oatmeal cookies, two Toffee Talk cookies, and three snickerdoodle cookies.
A Chocolate-Lover's Dream: Brooklyn Blackout Co. Brooklyn Blackout Cookie Tin
If you're the ultimate chocolate-lover, the Brooklyn Blackout Co. Brooklyn Blackout Cookie Tin [9] ($59) is something you'll love munching on. The tin contains 18 dark, rich chocolate cookies dipped in a delish chocolate glaze.
Sweet and Salty: T-Rex Cookie Company Giant Five Pound Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookie
Get something sweet, salty, and huge like this T-Rex Cookie Company Giant Five Pound Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookie [10] ($89) and truly indulge. The oversize cookie is filled with chocolate chips and caramel bits and topped off with a sprinkle of sea salt. It's so big, it can serve up to 30 people.
The Cookie Joint Cookie Fries Gift Basket — 6 Cartons
The Cookie Joint Cookie Fries Gift Basket [11] ($65 for six cartons) is a unique treat for any cookie connoisseur. They are shortbread cookies that are cut to look like crinkle fries. Choose between flavours like the original shortbread, chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, cookies n' cream, cinnamon spice, chocolate toffee crunch, confetti, green mint chocolate chip, red velvet, and lemon poppyseed or a mix. You can even add dipping sauces like chocolate and marshmallow!
Something Colourful: Baked in Colour Rainbow Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Indulge your sweet tooth and love of colour with this Baked in Colour Rainbow Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake [12] ($65). It serves around eight people.
Chocolate vs. Vanilla: William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies
If you can't decide between chocolate and vanilla, the William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies [13] ($59 for 12) are made for you. They're soft cookies topped with half dark chocolate and half vanilla icing.
Something Shareable: Cindy Lou's Cookies Giant Cookies
The Cindy Lou's Cookies Giant Cookies [14] ($79 for 12) are perfect for sharing. Each cookie can serve up to two people. They come with a chocolate chip cookie, a Nutella swirl cookie, a red velvet with cream cheese swirl cookie, a Captain Crunch cookie, a peanut butter marshmallow and toffee cookie, an oatmeal raisin cookie, a lemon cloud cookie, a white chocolate macadamia nut cookie, a salted chocolate truffle cookie, a guava coconut macaroon cookie, a coconut chocolate chip cookie, and a brownie krispy crunch cookie.
For Ina Garten Fans: Barefoot Contessa Ina's Favourite Cookies
If you're a fan of Barefoot Contessa, you'll fall in love with Ina Garten's Barefoot Contessa Ina's Favourite Cookies [15] ($59 for 12). They come with three chocolate chunk walnut cookies, three chocolate white chocolate chunk cookies, three oatmeal raisin cookies, and three peanut butter chocolate chunk cookies.
For Cookies-and-Cream Fans: Callie's Hot Little Biscuit Cocoa & Cream Cookies
If you're all about the cookies and cream, the Callie's Hot Little Biscuit Cocoa & Cream Cookies [16] ($36 for 12) are a sweet treat you'll order more than once. They're two dense dark chocolate cookies with a fluffy sweet cream filling.
Something Parisian: Ladureé Prestige Pink
Get a slice of Paris right at your doorstep with the Ladureé Prestige Pink [17] ($46 for 12 macarons). Macaron flavours include lemon, rose, vanilla, salted caramel, passion fruit, chocolate, pistachio, and more.