Update Consent

Best Halloween Cocktail Recipes

From a Death Eater's Negroni to a Vampire's Kiss, These Halloween Cocktails Are a Ghastly Delight

Oct 31 2020

Cheers to Halloween! What could be better than a night of dressing up, indulging in your favourite candy, and drinking eerily cool cocktails? Nothing — plain and simple. And thanks to these killer cocktail recipes, you'll enjoy an evening of all of that, along with a good buzz. Whether you're looking for the perfect autumn-inspired refreshment or you're drawn to the Harry Potter-themed libations, these drinks will make you wish it were 5 o'clock all autumn long. From pumpkin-based punches to eerily enchanting potions, these drinks will have you spellbound throughout the season. Take a look at the best Halloween-themed cocktails, and cheers to a bone-chillingly fun night ahead!

— Additional reporting by Haley Lyndes

Image Source: Half Baked Harvest

1. Halloween White Wine Sangria

This Halloween sangria looks spectacular with minimal effort — and it only requires three ingredients!

Get the recipe: Halloween white wine sangria

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Arturo Torres

2. Firewhisky

Ogden's Old Firewhisky and Blishen's Firewhisky are a few popular brands of the alcohol said to create a burning sensation while consumed and to inspire courage. While it's not entirely known what's in it, we imagine it to be like homemade Fireball, a combination of whiskey, cinnamon, and spicy chilis.

Get the recipe: firewhisky

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography

3. Vampire's Drip

Eek! We have chills over how cool this cocktail is. If you like sweets, you'll love this concoction. It's a mix of rum, Kahlúa, a splash of vanilla, a dash of milk, and a drizzle of sweetened condensed milk. It's perfect for a cosy night in, so fill up your cup!

Get the recipe: vampire's drip

4. Pumpkin Patch Punch

Tell us, is there anything better than a big bowl of punch? We think not. (Especially when it's this autumn-flavoured drink!) It's concocted with apple cider, orange juice, lemon, spiced pumpkin butter, vodka, and brandy, and you'll want to make an extra batch of this because it's just that good.

Get the recipe: pumpkin patch punch

Watch This!

Pop Quiz

Watch the Cast of Fear Street Play a Creepy Game of Horror Movie "Would You Rather"

5. The Dementor's Kiss

Eerie, alluring, and mysterious, this Harry Potter-inspired libation will steal your soul the show. Whip up a homemade spiced syrup, add Kahlúa and chocolate vodka, and you'll be sipping on this enchanting drink all night long.

Get the recipe: the Dementor's kiss

6. Smoky Harvest Apple Cider Margarita

Indulge in the best flavours of the season when you make this apple cider margarita. Smoky mezcal, orange liquor, spiced apple cider, and sweet maple are just some of the notes you'll taste in this libation. Top it off with fresh rosemary, apple slices, and a cinnamon stick for best results.

Get the recipe: smoky harvest apple cider margarita

7. Smoking Blackberry Sage Margarita

This blood-red libation will impress all margarita fans. Not only is it sinfully delicious, but it's also enchanting to look at. Dry ice for the win!

Get the recipe: smoking blackberry sage margarita

8. Monsteritas

Calling all margarita-lovers! Put a Halloween spin on your favourite drink when you make these delightful monsteritas. They're basically a healthy margarita that's spiked with cucumbers and jalapeños, sweetened with honey, and decorated to your desire.

Get the recipe: monsteritas

9. The Hermione Granger Cocktail

Harry Potter fans, this one's for you! Sweet and punchy, this charming cocktail features all the best qualities of Hermione Granger. Made with fresh raspberries, raspberry jam, rosemary, and vodka, this drink will cast a spell on all those who try it.

Get the recipe: the Hermione Granger cocktail

10. Whiskey Apple Cider

Ring in fall like never before when you make this glorious cocktail. It's made with hard cider, apple cider, bitters, and a shot of whiskey or bourbon, so you'll taste all the best flavours of the season with every sip you take.

Get the recipe: whiskey apple cider

11. Fig Bourbon Cider Smash

Say hello to autumn when you whip up this tasty drink. Made with fresh apple cider, tangy oranges, and sweet fig preserves, this bourbon-based cocktail will have you wishing it were 5 o'clock all the time.

Get the recipe: fig bourbon cider smash

12. The Black Widow Smash

This black widow smash is both delightful and chilling. Fresh blackberries are muddled with rosemary, lemon, a dash of orange bitters, and tequila, meaning this is both refreshing and enchanting.

Get the recipe: the black widow smash

13. Haunted Orchard Cocktail

Cheers to fall! This festive drink has all the best autumnal flavours, plus a hefty dose of tequila. It's sweet and flavourful, and it has a kick, thanks to the hard cider.

Get the recipe: haunted orchard cocktail

14. Sleepy Hollow Cocktail

If you want a bone-chillingly good drink (who doesn't?), this cocktail is for you. Pomegranate juice and tequila go hand in hand to make this dark drink, along with a dash of bitters, a touch of cinnamon, and rosemary-infused orange honey simple syrup. Yum, yum, yum.

Get the recipe: Sleepy Hollow cocktail

15. Pumpkin Pie Punch

You'll get the best of both worlds when you make this sweet punch. With apple cider, real pumpkins, and cream soda, this drink tastes as wonderful as a fresh slice of pumpkin pie. Top it off with a dollop of Cool Whip if you really have a sweet tooth.

Get the recipe: pumpkin pie punch

16. Poison Apple Martini

Made with only a few ingredients, this poison apple martini will enchant all those who drink it. Apple cider, vodka, and a little dry ice work together to create one of the most spellbinding drinks of the season. Cheers!

Get the recipe: poison apple martini

17. Harvest Apple Mule

Make the most of mules when you concoct this enticing drink. Vodka, apple cider, lemon juice, and ginger beer work together to make this drink hit your taste buds in all the right places.

Get the recipe: harvest apple mule

18. Vampire's Kiss

Dying to get drinks with Dracula? Good! This lemon-based martini will instantly cast a spell on you. To give it a spooky twist, rim the glass with red gel frosting, and your worst nightmares will come true.

Get the recipe: vampire's kiss

19. Blackberry Bourbon Smash

Need a cocktail, and need it quick? This easy-to-make drink is here for you. Combine fresh blackberries, a handful of mint, and a dollop of honey. Then, mix in a touch of lemon juice and muddle it all together. Add some bourbon (as much as you please), and toss in some ice. Top it off with ginger beer and sliver of mint, and you'll be cheers-ing in no time.

Get the recipe: blackberry bourbon smash

20. Bourbon Spiced Cider Cocktail

Even if you're not the biggest fan of bourbon, you'll still enjoy this drink. It's easy to make and absolutely delicious. It also doesn't taste super strongly of bourbon, thanks to the rich apple cider.

Get the recipe: bourbon spiced cider cocktail

21. Purple People Eater Colour-Changing Cocktail

Want to make a drink that'll impress more than just your taste buds? Whip up this colour-changing cocktail! It's made with a mix of cranberry juice, lemon juice, gin, and St-Germain elderflower liqueur, and it's just as tasty as it is beautiful.

Get the recipe: Purple People Eater colour-changing cocktail

22. Apple Butter Old Fashioned

There's nothing quite like snuggling up on a chilly autumn night with this cocktail in hand. Homemade apple butter, cider, lemon, orange bitters, bourbon, and ginger beer turn this libation into an autumn favourite in no time.

Get the recipe: apple butter old fashioned

23. Haunted Highball

This haunted highball is ghoulishly good. It's a white chocolate drink combined with a splash of hazelnut liqueur, so your mouth will be watering before you finish making it. Use a dry-erase marker to draw a ghostly scene on your cup, and your work here is done.

Get the recipe: haunted highball

24. Star Anise Spiced Apple Margarita

This margarita is just as refreshing as a crisp autumn day. It's sweet and simple while still offering big flavour, thanks to the rich apples. Plus, you'll learn how to make a star anise spiced simple syrup.

Get the recipe: star anise spiced apple margarita

25. Tequila Berry Smash

With just a couple of ingredients, you can make this mouthwatering drink in five minutes flat. Mixed berries, agave tequila, lime juice, and honey simple syrup are all you need to make this refreshing smash. Cheers to that!

Get the recipe: tequila berry smash

26. The Death Eater Negroni

Muggles, watch out! The Death Eater negroni is not meant for those without magical powers. However, if you want to test your chances, it sounds very good. Made with gin, Campari, sweet vermouth, and pomegranate juice, this negroni is lip-smackingly good.

Get the recipe: Death Eater negroni

Image Source: Half Baked Harvest

27. The Half-Blood Prince Cocktail

Inspired by the Harry Potter series, this blood-red cocktail consists of pomegranate, bourbon, Chambord, and lemon. The drink is devilishly delicious and makes for quite a spooky sight.

Get the recipe: the Half-Blood Prince cocktail

Image Source: Half Baked Harvest

28. Butterbeer

As we know, butterbeer isn't a real-life drink (sorry, Potterheads!), so every recipe of the drink calls for something different. This one, in particular, isn't too sweet or rich, making it easy to slug down.

Get the recipe: butterbeer

Image Source: Cooking Classy

29. The Deathly Hallows Cocktail

Become "the master of death" with the Deathly Hallows cocktail. Made with cranberry juice, mezcal, orange liqueur, lemon juice, maple, and ginger beer, this cocktail is a breeze to sip on.

Get the recipe: Deathly Hallows cocktail

Image Source: Half Baked Harvest

30. Pumpkin Butterbeer Hot Chocolate

Make butterbeer THAT much better with this creamy pumpkin-flavoured hot chocolate recipe. The secret ingredient is milk chocolate, and it tastes delicious with whipped cream and butterscotch drizzled on top.

Get the recipe: pumpkin butterbeer hot chocolate

Image Source: Half Baked Harvest

31. The Golden Snitch Cocktail

Influenced by Harry Potter's Golden Snitch, this bubbly drink is made with sweet apple cider, whiskey, St-Germain, lemon, maple, and a few spices. Rim a glass with cinnamon sugar, and you have the perfect cocktail to sip while reading the series (for the 100th time).

Get the recipe: Golden Snitch cocktail

Image Source: Half Baked Harvest

Want More?

POPSUGAR Would Like To Send You Push Notifications.