Update Consent

Best and Most Comfortable Mattresses

Mattress Shopping Made Easy: Customers Always Buy These 7 Top-Rated Picks

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

Most mattresses last anywhere between seven to 10 years, which is why buying a new one is a big commitment. If it's something you're going to have for nearly a decade, you want to make sure it's the best option for you. Shopping online can make it even harder to choose, because you're not actually trying it out. Luckily though, customer reviews can make it easier to shop. We love looking to these testimonials to see exactly what people are saying and buying, so you can feel like you made a good purchase before it even arrives.

To help you find your match, we did the hard work and shopped at sites like Amazon and Wayfair, which have thousands of affordable options to choose from. We broke it down by category and the highest-rated picks to find the best of the best. Whether you're looking for something to keep you cool or a hybrid choice, it's all here. Keep reading to shop our seven top picks.

Image Source: Wayfair

Wayfair Sleep 10" Medium Memory Foam Mattress

The Wayfair Sleep 10" Medium Memory Foam Mattress ($170-$320) is one of the most popular picks online. From Wayfair's in-house line, it currently has over 30,000 positive reviews, so you know its a solid choice. Customers rave that the price and quality are both impressive.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Wayfair Sleep 10" Medium Memory Foam Mattress
$170
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Casper Element Mattress

If you've always dreamed of owning a plush Casper mattress, you might want to try the comfy Casper Element Mattress ($395-$795). It's one of the brand's more affordable versions to shop. It doesn't lack in quality though, as it's one of the highest-rated picks.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Casper Element Mattress
$395
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Cool Gel 12" Medium Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Made with cooling technology and hypoallergenic materials, the Cool Gel 12" Medium Gel Memory Foam Mattress ($205-$420) is a great choice for sweaty sleepers.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Cool Gel 12" Medium Gel Memory Foam Mattress
$205
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Zinus Ultima 10" Comfort Memory Foam Mattress

The green tea-infused Zinus Ultima 10" Comfort Memory Foam Mattress ($174-$337) not only comes in numerous sizes but also a variety of thicknesses, too. You can choose a six-, eight-, 10-, or 12-inch thickness, depending on the support you're looking for. A lot of customers purchased the 10-inch choice and loved it.

Image Source: amazon.com
Zinus Ultima 10" Comfort Memory Foam Mattress
$174
from amazon.com
Buy Now

Watch This!

Pop Quiz

Watch the Cast of Fear Street Play a Creepy Game of Horror Movie "Would You Rather"

Nora 12" Medium Memory Foam Mattress

If you're looking for something that isn't too firm or too soft, then the Nora 12" Medium Memory Foam Mattress ($280-$550) is a great option. Made with medium-level memory foam, customers say it's just the right amount of comfort.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Nora 12" Medium Memory Foam Mattress
$280
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Linenspa 10 Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress

This Linenspa 10 Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress ($160-$360) is a great hybrid option, that is made with both memory foam and innersprings. Both combine together for a medium level of support and help to eliminate pressure points for a more comfortable night's sleep.

Image Source: amazon.com
Linenspa 10 Inch Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress
$160
from amazon.com
Buy Now

Tuft & Needle Original Mattress

With over 9,000 reviews, the brand boasts that 95 percent of customers keep and love the Tuft & Needle Original Mattress ($350-$638). Not only is made with no harmful chemicals, it's also made to help keep you cool all night.

Image Source: amazon.com
Tuft & Needle Original Mattress
$350
from amazon.com
Buy Now

Want More?

POPSUGAR Would Like To Send You Push Notifications.