Update Consent

The Best Mattresses From Wayfair

7 Popular Mattresses Wayfair Customers Always Buy and Truly Love

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

Mattress shopping in-store seems like a thing of the past. Thanks to the internet, it's easier than ever to find the right one for you and simply order it to your doorstep. You might wonder how can you decide on something you haven't even tried? The help of customer testimonials and in-depth reviews are the best way to see what's so great about them. One site we love looking to for this is Wayfair, because it has thousands of choices to shop with so many reviews.

We curated a list of the most popular choices it has to offer. From a choice with over 30,000 reviews (yes, really), to an option from the popular brand Casper, there is no shortage of good picks ahead. We even included important details on their comfort levels and thicknesses to make shopping simple. These affordable and bestselling finds will make picking the right match easy. Keep reading to shop them all.

Image Source: Wayfair

Wayfair Sleep 10" Medium Memory Foam Mattress

The Mattress: Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress ($210, originally $250)

Comfort Level: Medium

The Thickness: 10 inches

Why People Love It: If you're all about buying the best pick according to reviews, then this is your match. It currently boasts over 33,000 positive reviews, so what else do you need to know?

Image Source: wayfair.com
Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress
$210
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Wayfair Sleep 8" Medium Memory Foam Mattress

The Mattress: Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress ($185, originally $400)

Comfort Level: Medium

The Thickness: 8 inches

Why People Love It: If you're not too picky about mattresses and just want something affordable, you can't go wrong here. Not only it is on major sale right now, but it's also been reviews by over 15,000 customers.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress
$185
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Wayfair Sleep 10" Medium Firm Memory Foam Mattress

The Mattress: Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress ($250, originally $555)

Comfort Level: Firm

The Thickness: 10 inches

Why People Love It: If you're on the market for something that's firm, this memory foam choice is for you. Not only is it top-rated, but it's also afforable.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress
$250
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Cool Gel 14" Medium Gel Memory Foam and Memory Foam Mattress

The Mattress: Cool Gel Memory Foam and Memory Foam Mattress ($390, originally $436)

Comfort Level: Medium

The Thickness: 14 inches

Why People Love It: Made with gel memory foam that keeps you cool all night, this is a great option for sweaty sleepers.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Cool Gel Memory Foam and Memory Foam Mattress
$390
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Watch This!

Pop Quiz

Watch the Cast of Fear Street Play a Creepy Game of Horror Movie "Would You Rather"

Sealy 12" Plush Memory Foam Mattress

The Mattress: Sealy Memory Foam Mattress ($470, originally $999)

Comfort Level: Plush

The Thickness: 12 inches

Why People Love It: The memory foam mattress is made with low motion transfer technology, so if you're sleeping with someone who tosses and turns all night, you're less likely to feel it.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Sealy Memory Foam Mattress
$470
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Casper Element Mattress

The Mattress: Casper Element Mattress ($595)

Comfort Level: Firm

The Thickness: 10 inches

Why People Love It: The Element is one of the brand's more affordable options and is made with breathable techinolgy to help keep you cool.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Casper Element Mattress
$595
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Wayfair Sleep 11" Plush Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress plush

The Mattress: Wayfair Sleep Plush Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress ($400, originally $443)

Comfort Level: Plush

The Thickness: 11 inches

Why People Love It: If you're looking for a soft, plush, and cloud-like feel, this is a great choice for you. Customers who were looking for that, said they got the best night's sleep in years.

Image Source: wayfair.com
Wayfair Sleep Plush Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress
$400
from wayfair.com
Buy Now

Want More?

POPSUGAR Would Like To Send You Push Notifications.