My Toddler Used to Hit — This Is How We Stopped It

It goes against every natural instinct I have to completely ignore when my son hits his sibling or another child, but nothing I tried worked until I tried this. And I have Ralphie Jacobs of Simply on Purpose to thank (seriously, if you have kids of any age you need to follow her!).

The basic philosophy that Ralphie teaches is that you shouldn't be giving attention to inconsequential negative behaviours, or behaviours that are mostly attention seeking and not intended to do real damage. Her mantra is, "water the flowers, not the weeds." Often, hitting is an attention seeking weed rather than a deliberate attempt to cause harm, so giving attention to it just makes it grow.

Author Catherine Pearlman backs this idea up (she even wrote an entire book titled, Ignore It!). "It may sound counterintuitive, but sometimes ignoring your child is the perfect response. Any reaction to these annoying behaviours will merely serve as a negative reward, which actually encourages the behaviour to continue."

For me, quite literally walking away when my toddler hits his sibling is often enough to diffuse the situation. But if he can't get control of his emotions and doesn't stop hitting, I will sometimes, without saying anything, calmly remove him from the situation and put him in his room for a break. I don't know if Ralphie would recommend this, but it's my way of following her other advice to "ignore the behaviour, not the child" and seems to be effective in more escalated situations.

If both he and his brother don't stop even after I've ignored them or if they are continuing to figuratively poke at each other, I will try to change the situation. I still ignore the hitting and fighting, but I'll go over and say, "Boys, it's time to play outside!" or prompt them to move onto another activity. Often, simply redirecting them gets them to snap out of it.

It's when your child isn't hitting that you need to do the opposite of ignore and praise the sh*t out of them. Tell them how nicely they are playing with their friend when they actually are. Speak up when they share and give them props for being kind to their siblings. According to Ralphie, ignoring a negative behaviour only works when you also "look for the flower and pick it."

If I've literally turned my back and busied myself with something else after seeing my toddler hit his brother, I wait until he stops that behaviour and does something positive to give him attention or engage with him again. Or, if his brother is trying to play nicely, I focus my attention on him instead.