Update Consent

Foundation Tips For Women of Colour

How Fenty Beauty Changed the Way I Choose Foundation — For Better or For Worse

As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work.

To whom much is given, much is required, right? That's how the saying goes, yet never in a million years did I think it would apply to my foundation. Case in point: last year, Rihanna — the global pop star who gave us our favourite good-girl-gone-bad hits like "We Found Love," "Umbrella," and "Work" — launched Fenty Beauty, which changed the game by introducing 40 inclusive foundation shades. Finally, a makeup line we — people of colour and all skin tones — could wear. You would think all my cosmetic nightmares would be put to bed, but instead, my discernment in choosing just one shade to match my complexion grew weary.

For the sake of greed, and finally being able to order numerous tones from a single cosmetic line, I got antsy and ended up ordering four varying foundation shades.

On one end of the spectrum, I was elated that WOC now have multiple options to choose from like everyone else. On the other, it was tricky navigating this space because it's completely foreign to me. All of a sudden, what I demanded makeup-wise was far greater than what I could've imagined a year prior to the birth of Fenty.

Even though the brand's website does a considerable job matching colours to pictures of 40 diverse skin tones of models, I could not determine online which Fenty Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation was for me. I got picky. So for the sake of greed, and finally being able to order numerous tones from a single cosmetic line, I got antsy and ended up ordering four varying foundation shades.

Between pigments 380, 390, 400, and 410, I didn't think any of them resembled me at first. As the days went on, I took fancy to the colours and began to love my options. Some days I reveled in hue 400; on others, it was 380. In the Winter, I tend to look lighter, and when I travel, I get tan. However, I knew dabbling between four foundations was impractical — it's too much to swatch all four bases in the morning and travel with them on trips — and that I needed to edit down for money purposes (the bottles go for $34 a pop, which adds up to $136 for me) and also my sanity.

Not sure where to start, I reached out to celebrity makeup artists to figure out how they navigate this new space of beauty. Do they stick to one foundation or blend multiple? How do they match their clients' skin tones on the regular with one makeup kit? Keep reading to see what they had to say about their favourite products for people of colour, plus tips on how to wear them.

Image Source: POPSUGAR Photography / Noel Cymone Walker

Expert: Nadyne T. Hicks is Black-ish's makeup artist

"The face is my canvas, and my main goal is to even the skin with a light foundation application. I strive to enhance the face, not change it, so I don't apply heavy foundation unless the goal is to alter the face."

"When working with a client, I look at their skin undertones and begin my blending process from there. One tool I must have is a wooden handle bendable spatula to mix (sold at Nigel or Frends beauty supply in Southern California)."

Ben Nye Royal Spatula D-34 ($10)

Ben Nye Royal Spatula D-34
$10
from frendsbeauty.com
Buy Now

"I dabble a few products on a pallet in the same undertone family and blend with the spatula. I apply slowly by stippling (a pat drag process) with The Original Beautyblender ($20) sponge."

The Original Beautyblender
$20
from beautyblender.com
Buy Now

"I became a blender because I realised that skin has an undertone and that was not being represented in foundations for women of colour. A few of my favourite makeup brushes are It Cosmetics Heavenly Luxe Complexion Perfection Brush #7 ($48) and NYX Pro Dual Fibre Foundation Brush ($19)."

It Cosmetics Heavenly Luxe Complexion Perfection Brush #7
$48
from ulta.com
Buy Now
NYX Pro Dual Fibre Foundation Brush
$19
from nyxcosmetics.com
Buy Now

Watch This!

Pop Quiz

Watch the Cast of Fear Street Play a Creepy Game of Horror Movie "Would You Rather"

"Foundations used to make [women of colour] look ashy, grey, or green, and I didn't feel comfortable having a client in front of a camera like that. However, I also use foundations by Make Up For Ever like the Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Foundation Invisible Cover Foundation ($43), RCMA, and It Cosmetics."

Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Foundation Invisible Cover Foundation
$43
from makeupforever.com
Buy Now

"I like the Bobbi Brown foundations like the Skin Long-Wear Weightless Foundation SPF 15 ($46), and I love what Rihanna has done with Fenty Beauty. I like these two because it seems like they considered the undertones in the skin of women of colour."

Skin Long-Wear Weightless Foundation SPF 15
$46
from bobbibrowncosmetics.com
Buy Now

"Once I see the undertones, which are usually yellow or red, I then choose the foundations accordingly. I like Chanel's Les Beiges Healthy Glow Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 25 ($60), Revlon, True Match, and NYX."

Chanel's Les Beiges Healthy Glow Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 25
$60
from bloomingdales.com
Buy Now

"Face Atelier Ultra Foundation Pro ($36) is a great product because it has the primary colours and I can customize foundations by adding a drop of red or yellow into the base that I am using to create the perfect shade."

Face Atelier Ultra Foundation Pro
$36
from alconemakeup.com
Buy Now

"I love Visiora PC, Compact Powder, 105 Dark Warm Brown ($50) for contouring and shading."

Visiora PC, Compact Powder, 105 Dark Warm Brown
$50
from alconemakeup.com
Buy Now


"I use a fan brush, like the size and shape of the E.l.f Fan Brush ($4)."

E.l.f Fan Brush
$4
from target.com
Buy Now

Expert: Aaliyah Jay is the makeup artist to Nicki Minaj and a YouTube beauty vlogger.

"I love blending different foundations, and I love blending them with a beauty sponge to get a flawless canvas and have amazing pictures when the flash hits."

"I love Anastasia Beverly Hills Stick Foundation ($25) as contour sticks because they have a large shade range."

Anastasia Beverly Hills Stick Foundation
$25
from anastasiabeverlyhills.com
Buy Now

"I like to wear foundation that matches my skin perfectly, like the Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Foundation ($8)."

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Foundation
$8
from maybelline.com
Buy Now

"L.A. Girl Pro Coverage Liquid Foundation ($9) in White makes any foundation lighter. To darken your foundation shade, I suggest you mix a bit of dark concealer or any formula you use for your contour on the back of your hand."

L.A. Girl Pro Coverage Liquid Foundation
$9
from ulta.com
Buy Now

"Maybelline Facestudio Master Chrome Metallic Highlighter Makeup ($10) works on every complexion, but it's the best for girls of colour and is super inexpensive."

Maybelline Facestudio Master Chrome Metallic Highlighter Makeup
$10
from ulta.com
Buy Now

"Always match your foundation to your neck. I love the Giorgio Armani Foundation ($64)."

Giorgio Armani Foundation
$64
from sephora.com
Buy Now

Expert: Camara Aunique is the celebrity makeup artist to Ava DuVernay, Yvonne Orji, and June Ambrose and is a beauty expert for Juicy magazine.

"Blending is a part of the art of makeup. If I don't blend the makeup, it won't sit on the skin properly. I want my clients to not look heavy, and blending allows the makeup to finish like skin."

"I do not mix foundations and concealers to get the right colour, but a favourite concealer I'm using now is MAC Studio Fix 24-Hour Smooth Wear Concealer ($22)."

MAC Studio Fix 24-Hour Smooth Wear Concealer
$22
from maccosmetics.com
Buy Now

"Foundation normally works best by itself, or the formula will change and it'll become very heavy. I use the Kevyn Aucoin The Etherealist Foundation ($58)."

Kevyn Aucoin The Etherealist Foundation
$58
from sephora.com
Buy Now

"I love Danessa Myricks foundations ($28). The colours range from warms to neutrals so I can find the right colour for any person in my chair."

Danessa Myricks foundations
$28
from alconemakeup.com
Buy Now

"For the money-savvy person, I love the CoverGirl Queen Collection Bronzer ($13), and for the person who can spend, the Guerlain Terracotta Bronzing Powder ($53)."

CoverGirl Queen Collection Bronzer
$13
from amazon.com
Buy Now
Guerlain Terracotta Bronzing Powder
$53
from sephora.com
Buy Now

"The MAC Studio Conceal and Correct Duo ($26) makes a great colour corrector."

MAC Studio Conceal and Correct Duo
$26
from maccosmetics.com
Buy Now

"I love Cozzette, Nars brushes (like the Nars #23 Wet/Dry Blush Brush ($42), and the Beautyblender. I can do an entire face with a blender."

Nars #23 Wet/Dry Blush Brush
$42
from narscosmetics.com
Buy Now

Want More?

POPSUGAR Would Like To Send You Push Notifications.