"One of my biggest pet peeves about using an exfoliating peel pad — of which, it's worth noting, I am usually a big fan — is that it always strips me of my hard-earned spray tan. (Call me vain, but some days I'd rather maintain a Kardashian-level bronze than kick my dullness-inducing dead skin cells to the curb. Sue me.) Luckily, this M-61 PowerGlow Peel Gradual Tan Pad ($32) is the perfect in-between: not only does my skin get a glow from the exfoliating glycolic and salicylic acids, but I also get a subtle hint of tint, too. It's a win-win." — Kelsey Castañon, senior beauty editor