Lucy Hale wore a monochromatic cherry look that matched her dress, blush, and lipstick. The most eye-catching part of her makeup from the evening, however, was her bold lip, which was created with a $4 (yes, you read that right) lipstick by E.l.f. Cosmetics. Makeup artist Kelsey Deenihan created the look with the E.l.f. Cosmetics Moisturising Lipstick and Lip Colour ($4) in Red Carpet.