Though the storyline between Colton Underwood (Becca Kufrin's season) and Tia Booth (Arie Luyendyk's season) stole headlines on The Bachelorette this past Spring, the virgin football player has dated another notable figure: Aly Raisman, the gorgeous, two-time gymnastics Olympian. They met in mid-to-late 2016 after being set up by a friend on a blind date and continued their relationship through June 2017. Their breakup was caused busy schedules.
On an episode of The Bachelorette, Colton revealed that he'd only fallen in love once before, and while he didn't name names, we're guessing that his former love was none other than Aly.