Before there was Peter, there was Arie. Only a couple of months after their engagement — just as their season was starting to air, in fact — he ended his relationship with winner and fiancee Becca, instead choosing to pursue runner-up Lauren Burnham. The breakup, filmed in excrutiating detail, was one of the most controversial finales ever, but it seems like it all worked out for the best: Arie and Lauren are now married and have a daughter, while Becca became the next Bachelorette and is engaged to her final choice, Garrett Yrigoyen.