In April 2017, Bryant recounted the story of O'Malley's proposal gone wrong when she appeared on Late Night With Seth Meyers.
It all started when she got home from work to find her dog wearing a bow tie, and it was all downhill from there. "I was like, 'My dog doesn't wear a bow tie! Where is he going tonight?' Basically, the second I shut the door, a man — who I discovered was Conner — frantically came around the corner and was just like, 'Will you marry me?!' No box, no 'I love you.' ... Just a man in full terror standing very far from a dog in a bow tie, just holding a loose ring going, 'Will you marry me?!'"