While the exact dates of Lohan's relationship with Carter are unclear, the pair dated following the singer's romance with Hilary Duff. In 2005, Carter opened up about his relationship with both Duff and Lohan, telling CNBC: "I was dating [Hilary] for like a year and a half, and then I just got a little bored so I went and I started getting to know Lindsay." The popstar died in November 2022.