When Alicia Keys [1] stopped by The Late Late Show With James Corden [2] on Wednesday, she and Corden delighted viewers everywhere by teaming up to cover "Shallow" — well, sort of. Together the two remixed the hit song from A Star Is Born, swapping out the real lyrics for ones about Keys' upcoming Grammys hosting gig [3] — and two stars were born indeed.

Corden begins their parody by singing, "Tell me something Keys. I hear you're set to host this year's Grammys," to which the 38-year-old artist [4] croons back, "Didn't you host it twice? Maybe you could give me some advice." Shortly after Corden rattles off some of his pointers, Keys slips in a line from her iconic song, "Girl Is on Fire," sending the crowd into a round of applause. Watch their entire performance above, and you'll instantly become a Keys-Corden stan. Now, can these two actually cover the real "Shallow" [5]?