In the midst of all the leather, glitter, and deep v-necks in Jesus Christ Superstar Live!, there was a stripped-down performance that had us feeling instantly emotional. While some numbers in NBC's live musical — which prompted fans to share some seriously entertaining opinions on Twitter — were flashy, colourful affairs, Sara Bareilles's "I Don't Know How to Love Him" stands out because it's such a simple, quietly powerful rendition of the Andrew Lloyd Webber-written song. It's like Bareilles's voice was practically made to sing it. Watch it above, and then check out all the big musical moments from the show.