Since wrapping Charmed, the actress has had a few TV roles, most notably as Ella Montgomery on Pretty Little Liars. In 2015, she teamed up with her former costar, Shannen Doherty, for the travel show Off the Map With Shannen & Holly. She is also a mom to three sons, Finley, Riley, and Kelley, with her ex-husband David Donoho. In September 2017, she got engaged to her boyfriend Mike.