Starring Autumn Reeser — better known as The O.C.'s peppy Taylor Townsend — and Supernatural's David Haydn-Jones, this movie follows a man named Finn who tries to uncover the truth as to why his father left his nurse of two months, Willa, a large sum in his will before he died. When Finn going undercover to investigate the bed and breakfast the nurse has recently taken over, he discovers that Willa is not a scheming gold digger, but rather someone who put the money to good use. Taylor Townsend may not have been a good match for Ryan Atwood, but you'll definitely be feeling the chemistry between Finn and Willa.