Caitlin's entrance is getting ranked high on the list for the sheer insanity of what she does, which is both very funny and very aggressive. Dressed in a red dress and carrying a matching balloon, Caitlin strolls up to Colton like everyone else and then POP! She whips out a needle and pricks the balloon right in his face, saying, "Now that I've popped your cherry, we don't have to talk about virginity anymore." Colton's response? He tells the camera after she leaves that thought her balloon "was an apple." We're still laughing.