After her success in the 1990s as a child star, Fisk moved into music instead of focusing on acting, and she released her first album in 2009. In 2010, she teamed up with Tim Myers of OneRepublic to form the duo FM Radio — which brought her full circle back to the screen when they appeared as themselves in the CW series Hart of Dixie.
In recent years, Fisk has appeared in a handful of films and TV series. She had a guest spot on Fear the Walking Dead in 2016 and most recently appeared in the 2018 films The Nanny and Every Other Holiday.