Remember when Carly and Evan went on a date where they broke the Guinness World Record for "longest habanero pepper kiss" (much to Carly's dismay, at the time)? Yeah, they've come a long way since then. The adorable couple got engaged during the Bachelor in Paradise season three finale and married in Mexico, and Chris Harrison officiated their wedding. They welcomed a daughter, Isabella Evelyn, in February 2018 to join Evan's three sons. Their family will grow even more come November 2019 when their second child together is expected to arrive.