Who would have guessed that the only survivor of the '70s murders at Camp Redwood would actually be the real killer? Margaret Booth tries to convince her admirer, Benjamin "Mr. Jingles" Richter, to kill everyone who taunts them at the camp, and when he can't, she takes matters into her own hands. Margaret is so cold-blooded she cuts off her own ear to make it seem like she's one of the victims, then lets Mr. Jingles take the rap for it. Now that Mr. Jingles has returned to the camp, Margaret is back in serial killer mode with a very convenient scapegoat to take the fall.