In this romantic drama, a nerdy yearbook editor named Anne (played by Dylan Gelula, aka Xan from Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt) finds herself falling for the star of the softball team, Sasha (who's played by Brianna Hildebrand). Anne's crush becomes even more complicated after she confesses her growing attraction to Sasha to her best friend Clifton, only for Anne to learn that Clifton is in love with her.
Watch First Girl I Loved on Hulu.