Hannah Orenstein's Love at First Like follows sisters Eliza and Sophie Roth as they try to financially save their beloved jewellery shop nestled in the heart of New York City. After a late-night drunken mistake, it seems as though Eliza has found the answer: pretend she's engaged and use it the store's financial and popularity gain! With a ring, date, and half the wedding planned, Eliza realises she's just missing one important piece, a fiancé. Enter regal, entrepreneur Blake. As the lies start to pile up and deadlines approach, Eliza is in a big pickle. Of course, it also doesn't help she's falling in love with someone else, too.