The show stars Kaci Walfall as the titular Naomi. Joining her are Mary-Charles Jones as her best friend Annabelle; Barry Watson and Mouzam Makkar as her parents Greg and Jennifer; Cranston Johnson as mysterious car lot owner Zumbado; Alexander Wraith as tattoo parlor owner Dee; Daniel Puig as Naomi's ex-boyfriend Nathan; Aidan Gemme as Annabelle's boyfriend Jacob; Will Meyers as "proud townie" Anthony; and Camila Moreno as comic book enthusiast Lourdes.