Upon learning that he's being scouted by the Atlanta Braves, Ty finds his baseball coach flirting with his mother in their house. Ty is still angry about his dad's infidelity, and a sympathy present (the truck) causes a wedge between Ty and his brother Kyle, which only worsens throughout the season. Their childhood friend Annie also begins showing more of a romantic interest in Ty, not Kyle, causing even more tension.
During the finale, a fight between Ty and his high school nemesis breaks out at a prom afterparty. As a result, Kyle comes to Ty's rescue, but Ty wards him off, consequently hurting Kyle's feelings and leading him to take Ty's car keys and run away.