Lennon

The pilot episode presents the viewers with the key moments leading up to Lennon's death, which kicks off the show's main plot. At their graduation party, twin sisters Alison and Lennon get into an explosive argument when Alison finds out Lennon slept with her longtime crush, Dylan. After their fight, Alison bolts out of the room, and in her haste, she takes off with Lennon's jacket. She goes and sits in her car, in desperate need of an escape from the bustling party.

Meanwhile, when Lennon's group of friends see a cop on the premise, they run to avoid getting caught because they're drunk and high on drugs. They spot Alison sitting behind the wheel in Lennon's car (dressed and styled identically to her twin sister) and naturally assume she's Lennon and ask her to drive them away from the house. Alison, already emotionally distressed about her fight with Lennon, doesn't correct them and plays along. However, when she momentarily takes her eyes off the road while driving, she winds up accidentally hitting Lennon, who was walking on the road. When they check her pulse, they find, to their horror, that she's dead. However, Lennon's friends all believe it's Alison who's died, not their friend Lennon.

Coach Eric Craft, Johnny's Fiancé

A year after the accident, Johnny is now engaged to Eric (their former high school coach). While Alison (pretending to be Lennon) is the first one who receives the stalker's taunting message sprawled across her bedroom mirror in blood, Eric is, unfortunately, first to fall prey to their sinister machination in episode two. When Johnny drives to the gym to help Eric prepare for sports camp, he finds his fiancé motionless, trapped under a heavy barbell. Without realising the full scope of the trap, Johnny tries to remove the weights, only to release an adjoining dumbbell that pelts into Eric's face, killing him.

Johnny

As if seeing Eric smashed to death wasn't enough for one sitting, episode two comes to a bloody end with Johnny himself getting killed. The mysterious revenge-seeker repeatedly bludgeons Johnny over his neck until he's ultimately decapitated. Then, the murderer disposes of his severed head on the precise spot Lennon was killed last year, a foreboding signal for the rest of the witnesses from that night.

Dale

Dale is a good-for-nothing sleaze whom we see briefly stop by on the side of the road on the night Lennon is killed. As Alison grows increasingly suspicious in episode three that he's the murderer stalking and threatening her, she decides to go back to his workplace, Snak 'N Stuff, to confront him. But by the time she gets there, he's already been murdered. Thankfully, the showrunners spare the gruesome details of this particular slaughter. Instead, we get a final glimpse of his lifeless body, which gives insight into how he was killed: he has a plastic tube of Blue Crush slushy forced down his throat, leaving his corpse looking scarily blue, as if frozen to death.

Officer Doug Cruise

Doug is a colleague of Lyla, the chief sheriff of Wai Huna. While sifting through Dale's bank records following his murder, Doug tracks his bitcoin payments back to Lennon's OnlyFans account (where she would post explicit sexual content under her sister's username, @AllyWally). But before we could see him following up on this information, he becomes the show's next victim. Following last summer's incident, the OGs and the twins' father, Bruce, tell everyone Alison (aka Lennon) ran away and never came back, and they engineered a resentful note from Alison to back up their story. But when Lennon's body turns up in the water a year later, everyone believes the note was a suicide note.

When the town gathers to pay their respects to Lennon at her funeral, the mysterious killer pounces on the opportunity to do away with another victim. In the final moments of the third episode, Doug is found by Courtney (Riley's mother) in the bathroom of Bruce's restaurant with his throat brutally slashed open.