Trader Joe's Organic Maple Butter Personally, I like to mix the Trader Joe's Organic Maple Butter ($49 for 20 ounces) with my overnight oats for a deliciously luxurious taste. You'll need zero sweetener, and these jars last a very long time once opened and refrigerated. Image Source: amazon.com Trader Joe's Organic Maple Butter $49 from amazon.com Buy Now