Pisces: Starbucks Secret Menu Caramel Cookie Bar One of the most tolerant of the zodiac, this water sign is highly intuitive and compassionate. A Pisces can be selfless to the point of martyrdom, but they make excellent partners and friends. This sweet frap aligns with a Pisces because it's hard not to like. With a rich cookie flavour, this Starbucks drink is creative and unique — just like a Pisces.