NYX Professional Makeup On The Rise Volume Liftscara "I love that I can pile on the length and volume with the NYX Professional Makeup On The Rise Volume Liftscara ($11) without it ever clumping. The formula is extremely dark black and held my curled lashes all day." –Sarah Siegel, assistant beauty editor Image Source: ulta.com NYX Professional Makeup On The Rise Volume Liftscara $11 from ulta.com Buy Now