"This is a painfully cheesy pun to make here, but damn, this mascara is good. Even just looking at the wand — the Too Faced Damn Girl! 24-Hour Mascara ($25) has the same hourglass shape as its Better Than Sex counterpart, but bigger — you can tell it's here to make an impact. Not only did it give my lashes major volume, it also stayed put through a night of torrential downpour. And so, I repeat: damn." — KC