For Goodwin, the most striking feature of Alice in Wonderland's Cheshire Cat is its wide mouth. To create the mouth, use a creamy eye pencil in black draw its outline — which would extend from ear-to-ear — and the features of the teeth. Then, you can fill in the area with creamy eye pencils or colourful matte eyeshadows of your choice. Goodwin said to make sure to keep the lines of the mouth as crisp and clean as possible.
Nyx Professional Makeup has curated a bundle of products as part of its Wonderland After Dark Collection ($45) to achieve this exact look.