Too Faced Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette With an average 4.7-star rating out of more than 2,000 reviews, this sweet Too Faced Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette ($49) sure is popular . . . but its actual cocoa-powder-and-gold infusion is just icing on the cake. Image Source: sephora.com Too Faced Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette $49 from sephora.com Buy Now