Item: Wander Beauty Unlashed Volume and Curl Mascara ($12-$24)
What our editor said: "For something that was supposed to transform my lashes, I expected some innovative brush tip. Instead, I found a pretty mundane one — there were zero gimmicks, no weird wand, and no spiky bristles. It only had a slight curve at the end, and it turns out that was all I needed. Combined with a buildable formula, I went from having barely there hairs to fanned-out fringe in just a few swipes. . . With just one coat, they looked visibly longer, lifted, and separated. Three more coats gave me extra long, fluttering lashes that had a slight curl.
[This mascara] is a lash curler, mascara, and miracle-worker in one — keeping my lashes in line." — JMC
If you want to read more, here is the complete review.